advertisement
Shooting

Kimber Stainless II .38 Super 1911 Review: Tested in 300-Shot Arizona Range Session

Some pistols are tools. This polished .38 Super is also a piece of jewelry. See how it shot in the Arizona desert.

Kimber Stainless II .38 Super 1911 Review: Tested in 300-Shot Arizona Range Session
Commercial Partner
Testing, ratings and editorial conclusions remain independent.
Affiliate Links
We may earn a modest commission through links on this page at no extra cost to you.

There is a common attitude among serious gun owners that firearms are simply tools. While there is an obvious sense of truth to this, I believe they are much more.

They are highly valued pieces of our world and in many cases an extension of our personality. I believe this is why the looks of a gun matter. I mean, if it was truly a tool like a hammer, you would not care about the color or finish. But most people do care and that is why beautiful guns matter.

One of the most beautiful guns to cross my desk recently was the new Kimber Stainless II chambered in .38 Super, which debuted at REEDS' 32nd Annual Gun Fair held in Little Falls, Minnesota.

Kimber Stainless II .38 Super muzzle, trigger and safety details with the pistol at an outdoor range
All of the controls were top-notch, but the trigger truly stood out to the author, a veteran to the 1911 platform.

But assessing looks was only part of the assignment. Kimber sent me the pistol for a 300-round session on my Arizona desert range, using Federal American Eagle .38 Super +P 115-grain JHP. Most of the work took place from 3 to 15 yards, though one piece of steel at 75 yards proved too tempting to ignore. I wanted to know whether this serious bling gun shot as good as it looked—and whether it would make it through the day without a hiccup.

POLISHED CRAFTSMANSHIP
Kimber Stainless II .38 Super 1911
Stainless II .38 Super 1911
9.0
Out of 10
Drop-dead gorgeous, soft-shooting and reliable, this .38 Super is no safe queen.
Best for:
  • You want a classic 1911 with standout looks
  • You value mild recoil and a clean trigger
Know before you buy:
  • Its full-size steel frame adds carry weight
Jump to Final Verdict

Kimber Stainless II .38 Super Design and Finish

The new Kimber Stainless II .38 Super is a high-end 1911 with its slide, frame, and small parts all outfitted with a meticulously polished stainless-steel finish, giving the gun a very sophisticated appearance.

advertisement

Kimber has chosen a pair of G10 bonded smooth ivory grips for the gun which complement it nicely. The backstrap is checkered to give you a good purchase without being overly aggressive. The Stainless II uses an easy-to-aquire three-dot sight set in the dovetail.

advertisement

Where the gun really shines is in the trigger. Kimber has taken the time to fit the trigger which makes it smooth and clean. My trigger gauge showed a break at 4.5 pounds consistently.

For a modern, high-capacity take on polished stainless, our Kimber 2K11 Stainless Comp review tests its compensated design directly against the original 2K11.

What .38 Super Brings to the Stainless II

While the looks of the gun make it unique, Kimber has added an additional twist and chambered the gun in .38 Super. This round has been around since the 1920s and is impressive.

With 500-foot pounds of muzzle energy, and muzzle velocity beyond 1,300 feet per second with an FMJ bullet, it easily works in the personal defense world. It also produces recoil that is comparable to a 9mm making it a perfect round for shooting on the range or carrying concealed.

For a harder-hitting full-size alternative, our Kimber Comp X Hunter 10mm review covers a compensated stainless-steel 1911 built around hunting use

Kimber Stainless II Fit and Range Setup

Kimber was kind enough to send me a pistol to take out for a little test drive. When it arrived, I opened the box like a kid at Christmas. The fit and finish of the gun was spectacular. The pistol has an exceptionally high gloss finish that screams “bling.”

advertisement
advertisement

The slide and frame were mated well with no slop or twist between the two. The trigger sits inside the channel perfectly which eliminates any horizontal wiggle. To me, this is a big deal because it affects accuracy. The less the trigger wiggles, the more accurate you can be.

With the gun in hand, it was time to schedule a range session. My only apprehension was that I knew a range session would dirty the gun—especially shooting on my range in the Arizona desert. As you will see, however, I quickly got over that.

Shooter aiming the Kimber Stainless II .38 Super 1911 at an Arizona desert range
Mastison's 300-plus round range session resulted in zero hiccups. He even connected on steel out to 75 yards.

Kimber Stainless II Range Test: 300 Rounds in the Arizona Desert

Federal was kind enough to provide me with ammo. This range session would see me run Federal American Eagle .38 Super +P 115-grain JHP. This is solid ammo and comes in at the same bullet weight as most all 9mm. However, once I started shooting, it was clearly softer shooting than any 9mm.

As with most guns, I looked at the trigger of the Stainless II very closely and watched its performance. It is an excellent trigger and once again, the lack of play makes it a big help in getting tight groups.

The gun weighs in the 2.3-pound range which gives it sufficient weight to help manage recoil and muzzle rise. This all combined made the gun a fast and flat shooter. My splits were speedy, and my groups were solid with the pistol ammo combination.

While I ran a majority of my shooting in the 3- to 15-yard range, I did see a piece of steel calling me at 75 yards. On the buzzer, I drew the pistol and fired a round.

advertisement

Within a split second, the sound of the round hitting the steel rang out. Impressed with myself, I decided it was best to rest on my laurels and stick with the first-round hit. While it has only extremely rare real-world applications, the fact that the gun is accurate enough to do that is impressive.

I was able to shoot through all 300 rounds that Federal provided and I had no malfunctions at all. The magazines were made well and fed well. At the end of the day, I was pleased to find that the gun was not covered in carbon and dust. A tip of the hat to Federal and their clean powder.

Who the Kimber Stainless II .38 Super Is For

The Kimber Stainless II .38 Super 1911 is a two-fold exceptional gun. First, it is just drop-dead gorgeous and eye-catching. The second though is that it shoots as good as it looks. This is the perfect combination for any gun in my mind.

While you may not think you need a high-gloss 1911 in .38 Super in your life, I would disagree. I believe that everyone needs a serious bling gun that shoots as good as it looks. The gun I would steer you toward is the Kimber Stainless II.

Kimber Stainless II .38 Super 1911 with Federal American Eagle ammunition being loaded
Federal American Eagle .38 Super +P 115-grain JHP fed the new Kimber 1911 for this Hook & Barrel INSIDER review.

Kimber Stainless II .38 Super 1911 Review: Final Score & Verdict

POLISHED CRAFTSMANSHIP
Kimber Stainless II .38 Super 1911
Stainless II .38 Super 1911 (1 of 3)
Stainless II .38 Super 1911 (2 of 3)
Stainless II .38 Super 1911 (3 of 3)
Check prices at...
Affiliate disclosure: We may earn a modest commission at no extra cost to you
9.0
Out of 10
Excellent
Accuracy
9.0
A first-round steel hit at 75 yards from the draw.
Reliability
9.0
300 rounds fired with no malfunctions.
Handling
9.0
A fitted 4.5-pound trigger with no play, and 2.3 pounds of steel keeping muzzle rise flat.
Aesthetics
9.5
Meticulously polished stainless with G10 ivory-style grips.
Build Quality
9.0
Slide and frame mated with no slop or twist, and the trigger sits without horizontal wiggle.
Value
8.0
At $1,200 it is priced fairly for a fitted 1911.
Pros
  • Fitted trigger broke at a consistent 4.5 pounds
  • Slide and frame mated with no slop or twist
  • Polished stainless with G10 ivory-style grips
  • .38 Super recoils like a 9mm on the range
Cons
  • .38 Super is a niche cartridge
Product Origin
Manufacturer sample (Kimber supplied the pistol; Federal supplied the ammunition)
Test Type
Range (majority of shooting at 3 to 15 yards; single shot on steel at 75 yards from the draw)
Test Location
Author's range, Arizona desert
Rounds Fired
300
Ammunition Tested
Federal American Eagle .38 Super +P 115gr JHP
Instrumentation
Trigger gauge (4.5 pounds, consistent)
Accessories
None (factory three-dot sights)
Tested By
Fred Mastison
Caliber
.38 Super
Action
Single-action semi-automatic
Barrel
5 inches
OA Length
8.7 inches
Weight
2.375 pounds
Grips
G10 bonded smooth ivory
Sights
Front and rear white dot
Finish
High-polished stainless steel
Trigger
Measured at 4.5 pounds
Capacity
9+1
MSRP
$1,200

MORE FROM THIS BRAND

Standard Popup

Outdoor Lifestyle Doesn't Get Better than This

Join the other 240,000 outdoorsmen and sign up for our weekly emails to get the latest content, sneak previews, INSIDER updates, and more!